‘The Girl with the Dogs’ by Anna Funder


2014,  57 p.

This book is published as a Penguin Special, a series that is spruiked as

“concise, original and affordable… short enough to be read in a single setting- when you’re stuck on a train; in your lunch hour; between dinner and bedtime.”

Looking through the other titles in the series at the back of the book, they’ve engaged some good writers, mainly but not exclusively fiction.  I see that this novella was originally published as “Everything Precious” by Paspayley.  Paspayley? Publishers?  It’s only now, as I write this blog entry that I’ve remembered reading about this: Anna Funder (winner of the Miles Franklin back in 2012) was funded to write a short story aimed at a young female demographic by Paspayley Pearls.  The company had come in for some adverse publicity through a Four Corners episode in 2012 investigating the death of one of its pearl divers, and the company contracted Special Group advertising agency to produce a campaign aimed at a market that had not, until then, seen pearls as a fashion item.   A chapter of the book was released online each day, accompanied by a video clip featuring an actress wearing Paspayley pearls.  At the end of the week-long campaign, the whole book was available for download as a free e-book and in hard copy.  Of course, if I’d read the back cover, I would have known that it had been published online under a different title.

Learning all this changes the direction of my thinking about this book. I wonder how Penguin came to publish it, when it’s available online anyway? Is that why they changed the name?   I think I’d feel a little cross if I shelled out the $9.99 to buy it, only to find that I’d downloaded it for free six months earlier under another title.

In fact, I’d been thinking about the pricing of this book, even before I learned of its digital incarnation.  I read it in 45 minutes, and $9.99 seems rather expensive for less than an hour’s reading.  Then I remembered Weight Watchers (of all things). They consciously price their sessions to be the same price as a cinema ticket- enough to twinge, but a price comparable to a fairly common entertainment activity.  I suppose that movies go for about 100 minutes at $20.00 for a full-price ticket at Hoyts, so I guess that an hour’s reading (I’m a fairly fast reader) at $10.00 makes the book and a movie  somewhat comparable.  This all seems rather grubby and mercenary, but I must confess to feeling emboldened to pursue the idea now, knowing that the book was funded as a commercial venture in the first place.  Although all books are, I suppose: the difference lies in the fact that instead of a publisher funding it, a jeweller did.

As for the book itself: it is very much a modern story.  Tess is the mother of three children and the daughter of a widowed Judge now in an aged care facility; she has a career as a legal editor that takes her to international conferences; she has been married for seventeen years to Dan, an academic.  It’s a life of school-runs, mobile phones and i-pads. All this technology both suffocates and liberates, and it is through technology that she can find a man she knew and loved long ago.

Despite its modernity, the story is told in a detached, rather interior fashion, and to my shame, it was only when I read the Saturday Paper review of Funder’s book that I realized that it’s a Chekhovian voice that I’m hearing.  The story is a riff on Chekhov’s short story The Lady with the Dog (available online here), and realizing this, I have even more respect for what Funder has done with it. I shouldn’t imagine, though, that there will be many readers who will make the connection with the Chekhov story- I certainly didn’t.

This story is strong enough to stand as a novella in its own right, and I think that it would be stifled by being in a collection of short stories.   Tess is a nuanced character and her lifestyle and thoughts completely plausible, even for someone a good fifteen years older than she.  In my 45 minutes of reading, I experienced a full range of emotions: fear for her, a gooey warmth at the romance of it, an ending that satisfied.  In all this, the book is thoroughly self-sufficient. Nonetheless,  I can still imagine that Paspayley would have been delighted that she’d encapsulated their target market (Western, educated, wealthy, approaching middle aged without admitting it, female) so well.

aww-badge-2015-200x300I’ve read this as part of the Australian Women Writers Challenge.

7 responses to “‘The Girl with the Dogs’ by Anna Funder

  1. I read this as the free download and was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed it. Agree, though, that I’d have been very unhappy to buy it in this format and find it was the same story. Thanks for the heads up!

  2. Well, what a delightful post this is: I have been adventuring all over the web, starting with reading Chekhov’s delicious story, and then Sue’s and John’s review. And the comments… fascinating. But the Funder story? No, not even for free. I am a passionate admirer of Funder’s Stasiland but I was ambivalent about All That I Am when I read it and with the passage of time have now consolidated my view that I am unlikely to read her fiction again.

  3. Lisa – tell us why! You’ve left me on tenterhooks. Or have you already blogged about your reasons (in which case I’d love to read that post – can you point me in the right direction?)

  4. Oh no, I bought this a few days ago without looking at the back, and of course, as you know, I read and reviewed the free one! Sucked in! Actually I was looking for gifts for my brother and saw this along the way. A new Funder I thought? Well, I’ll buy it because it will make a good Christmas present if I decide not to read it myself! I do not give away books I read. Well, now I will include it in my Xmas gift pile.

    I thought it was well written but I did feel it was a little too geared to a target market, artistic freedom or not. It has not lingered with me I must say. I hadn’t read the Chekhov story either, though she did allude to him as I recollect.

  5. On my recent trip back to Australia I spent a lot of time in a bookshop one day looking for AWW books I’d like to read but maybe aren’t available internationally. I picked up this one… and then put it back for all the reasons you mention, mostly the price… and I’m usually very happy to buy books I want to read and don’t mind buying the occasion very brief work in translation.
    Maybe I should see if there is a free copy still lurking about 🙂

  6. Pingback: Australian Women Writers Challenge 2015 wrap up | The Resident Judge of Port Phillip

Leave a Reply to orangepekoereviews Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s