I hear with my little ear: Podcasts 24-31 October 2026

The Rest is History It must be time for a bit more Irish history. We recently watched the ‘Say Nothing’ series on SBS and so I was interested in catching up on these episodes. Episode 697: The Troubles: Murder in Belfast (Part 1) picks up on their last series on Ireland. With the partition of Ireland in 1922, 1/3 or 500,000 people in Northern Ireland were Catholic. It was a fault-line from the start, and neither side felt safe. In January 1939 the IRA launched its S-plan (sabotage plan) campaign of bombing and sabotage against the civil, economic and military infrastructure of the United Kingdom. As a result IRA members were interned during WW2, and the B-specials and Royal Ulster Constabulary acted as a form of Protestant militia. In 1963 Terrence O’Neil took over as Prime Minister, with plans to encourage investment in Northern Ireland but he was not popular. The Protestant preacher Ian Paisley was becoming increasingly strident. In May 1966 the first casualties of the Troubles occurred with the death of a Protestant grandmother killed by mistake.

The Alex Marlow Show. I’m looking into Effective Altruism for a talk that I’ll be giving to my UU group and somehow or other I ended up on this show which is part of the Bartbreit News Channel!! [I’ll probably be inundated with this stuff now]. The ‘Effective Altruism’ Cult Exposed with Theo Wold blames Hillary Clinton, Barak Obama and the British Labor Party for warning about AI, and says that Ilhan Omar gives AI slop speeches…yet somehow Donald Trump is the good guy here? It’s a whole other universe. Anyhow, it’s interesting that even these two buddies on the Right come up with similar suggestions to those coming from the Left: that any body established to supervise AI should not have the tech-bros on it; that data centres should be partially owned by the community and deliver ongoing community benefits; that we should be asking what this data centre is actually for before acquiescing.

The Book Club Episode 27: Brave New World: The Dystopia That Came True? Brave New World is set in AF (After Ford) 632 (AD 2540). As with Orwell’s 1984 (with which I always get it confused), it starts with a disaffected servant of the state and it’s rather “tell, don’t show”. In Dominic and Tabby’s view, Brave New World is lighter and more whimsical than 1984, and its characters are less significant than the ideas it stimulates. It was written in four months as a spoof on H. G. Wells and Los Angeles, and they feel that it reflects the British elitism of the 1920s and 30s. It is not really clear whether Huxley actually likes this world: it is dehumanizing but it is at least orderly and safe. Dominic gave it 5/10 because he doesn’t like novels of ideas, and thinks that as a novel, it’s rubbish. Tabby was slightly more generous, giving it 6/10.

The Conversation Finishing off the 6-part series from The Conversation website giving a step-by-step guide to becoming an autocrat, released in January 2026. Step 4: Beat the Courts is almost like a playbook of Trumps’ actions: attack the judges, stack the court with loyalists etc. Although Jefferson was not too keen on the equality of the Supreme Court with the Presidential branch, generally presidents have considered the Supreme Court and Presidency to be equal branches of government. This broke down with the Federalist Society, founded in 1982, and their Unitary Executive Theory, which Trump’s appointments to the Supreme Court uphold, which sees the Supreme Court acting deferentially to the Presidency. Paul Collins, a Supreme Court expert from the University of Massachusetts-Amherst (who features on this episode) looks for similar examples and finds them in Hugo Chavez’s expansion and purging of the courts in Venezuela, and Franco’s Spain where all crimes were described as ‘terrorism’, leading to trials that lasted minutes. The Supreme Court of the United States has granted Trump immunity, but post-Trump (come the day!) all of his executive orders will be able to undone with the stroke of a pen. Step 5: Suppress the People features Lucan Way, a professor of democracy at the University of Toronto. He points out that 2/3 of the autocrats today were initially elected, rather than taking over in a coup. The playbook is to purge the civil service of its career professionals. Politicized investigations lead to self-censorship. Hungary is (was) a model for this, with Orban undertaking constitutional reform (something that Trump hasn’t done), then moving on to the media, all done without resorting to violence. He points out that authoritarian regimes tend to affect only a proportion of the population, leaving everyone else to watch on but not be affected personally. In Step 6: Co-opt the Military Joe Wright, a political science professor at Penn State University has been a bit overtaken by events, as his certainty that US troops would shoot citizens was proven naive by the shootings of Renee Good and Alex Pretti. However, ICE and the FBI are now headed by loyalists (which Wright describes as people who would have no good career prospects unless their leader was in power). ICE is now the 15th largest military force in the world, but it (so far) has not arrested opposition politicians or media journalists. In terms of the U. S. Army, Trump started by replacing the military lawyers, appointing people with no command experience, then purging military officers who were not white, and not men. Wright looks at Russia and Syria where the Party placed political officers alongside military officers; and where a new or revitalized security body was appointed to act as a personalized security force more likely to shoot protesters.

‘The Granddaughter’ by Bernhard Schlink

2025, 336 p

For some time Bernhard Schlink has been writing about love, the burden of guilt, secrets and lives not lived, often within the context of post WW2 Germany. I read The Reader and Flights of Love some twenty years ago, before I started this blog. In his most recent book, written in 2024, he has moved beyond the immediate aftermath of WW2 to the context of Reunification, and the lingering nostalgia in Eastern Germany for the certainties and sense of mission of the Communist past. We’re seeing this play out politically before our eyes with the rise of AfD and its popularity in the former German Democratic Republic. But Schlink’s book is more about these politics playing out at the personal and emotional level.

Kaspar, a retirement-aged bookseller is grieving the death of his wife Birgit, who was found dead in the bath. Birgit had been born in East Germany, and they met as university students. He arranged Birgit’s crossing to West Germany, and like Orpheus, he knew that he could not look back to see if she was following. Birgit had been unhappy and drinking heavily for some years, but it is only when Kaspar reads through her never-finished memoir that he realizes that his wife has had a life largely unknown to him both before and during their marriage. Soon after meeting Kaspar she had had a daughter through a liaison with a married man much older than she was, and seemed to have been manipulated into continuing with the pregnancy in order for him to bring up a child with his childless wife. Although Kaspar was deeply in love with Birgit she had never really loved him in the same way and had kept a distance between them and embarked on journeys without him. She had considered seeking her daughter who was by now middle-aged, but had never followed through. But Kaspar takes on this task himself, largely out of love for her.

He tracks down Birgit’s daughter, Svenja, who is married to a harsh, brutish man in a völkisch rural neo-Nazi village. Svenja had had her own conflicts with her strict adoptive parents as an adolescent which perhaps explains her willingness to subjugate herself to her husband Bjorn, although she (perhaps like her mother) is strangely detached from any feelings of anger about her situation. Although he has no blood connection at all, Kaspar feels the strongest connection to Svenja’s teenage daughter, Sigrun. In a rather implausible plot leap, he arranges generous financial support for Svenja, and undertakes to host Sigrun for holidays during the year, pretending that these were the wishes of his deceased wife. Together they discover a shared love for music- indeed, Sigrun seems a very old teenager with very old tastes- but she is also thoroughly imbued with the Holocaust-denying, far-right politics of her parents and her involvement in street hooliganism with her peers.Kaspar knows that he must not try to change her politics lest Bjorn forbid any further contact, but already she is changed by her relationship with Kaspar.

It took me a while to warm to this book. I found the frame story of Kaspar’s relationship with Birgit and the long chapter of Birgit’s memoir a pretty clunky technique for such an experienced writer. I was sceptical of Kaspar’s arrangement with Svenja and Bjorn, and I don’t know whether I ever really believed in either Svenja or Sigrun- Svenja because she was so distant, and Sigrun because she seemed to have a 50 year old head on a 18 year old body. The book ended hastily: I can live comfortably with ambiguity and incompleteness, but the pacing seemed odd. The book picked up in the last third for me, with Schlink capturing well the discomfort of loving someone but hating their politics- something too many of us are having to face today.

My rating: 7/10

Sourced from: purchased e-book

Read because: Ivanhoe Reading Circle selection. I didn’t finish it in time, so I didn’t go to the meeting.

I hear with my little ear: Podcasts 16-23 October 2026

Background Briefing. Dark Menace series Mark Dennis was a Sydney criminal barrister who was found dead ‘with no suspicious circumstances’ in his home in inner Sydney after he had been investigated for child sex offences. Online he had used the name ‘Dark Menace’ (a spoonerism on his name) and it seems that he has been involved in questionable activities, especially related to a Cambodian orphanage run by Australian Geraldine Cox. This is a 3 part series, but it is interminably drawn out as a conversation between an investigative journalist and the host of the show, complete with lots of professions of shock and horror. It would have been interesting as a single episode but drawn out over three weeks I felt like shaking them and telling them to get on with the damned story.

History Extra Did the Catholic Church Support Hitler? featuring Ambrogio Caiani. By 1914 the Catholic Church had lost much of its political and diplomatic power, starting in 1905 when it broke links with Spain. It still had links with Austria-Hungary and Germany, so it was seen as pro-German. The Vatican became an unofficial listening post for Germany, and when the liberal democrats replaced authority in Austria-Hungary, the conservatives were looking for friends. Pius X had demanded that priests reject modernism, and in 1922 Pius XI reaffirmed Christ as King, with top-down authority. Although Mussolini was an atheist, he adapted after an electoral defeat to slowly bring in pro-Catholic legislation. With the 1929 Laterine Accord the Vatican was recognized as a sovereign state. Catholicism was recognized as the religion of Italy, but not the only one, and the Church decided not to oppose Mussolini’s dictatorship. But when Italy annexed Ethiopia, the Catholic Church accepted it grudgingly in spite of the problem that the Ethiopians were the oldest Christians. In 1938 Germany introduced its racial laws and Pius XI announced that ‘we are all semites’. When Hitler took power in 1933 the Catholic Church negotiated the Reich Concordate, which guaranteed the position of the Catholic Church in Germany and placed limits on the Church’s political action. The Nazis ignored the Church’s stance on schools and the euthanasia of disabled people. The Church neither collaborated with, nor defied, the roundups of Jewish people. Some were saved by individual churches and convents, but there is little evidence that this was official Church policy. Many leaders in the Catholic Church did know what was happening but were largely indifferent. By the end of WW2 fear of communism led to a perception that democracy and Catholicism were not incompatible. The Church played an ambiguous role: it opposed unconditional surrender, urged leniency for Nazi prisoners at Nuremberg and facilitated the flight of ex-Nazis to Latin America. And then the podcast abruptly ended!

The Rest is History They saved the best until last! Episode 682 South Africa: Mandela and the Death of Apartheid tells the story of the South African national anthem and its connection with 20th century South African history. With the introduction of apartheid in South Africa, the white 20% of the population dominated economic, political and sporting life. In 1981 South Africa faced international opprobrium in the form of a boycott of the Springboks and economic boycotts. When Nelson Mandela was released from jail in 1990 after serving 27 years, he was elected president of the ANC. Once South Africa was accepted back into the sporting world, the Rugby World Cup was scheduled to be held in South Africa in 1995 and Mandela, by then President, wanted the blacks to support the mainly white Springboks, and for the whites to accept singing a multi-racial song as anthem. “Nkosi Sikelel’ iAfrika” was composed by a Methodist school teacher named Enoch Sontonga in 1897.It was adopted by the African National Congress as its official song, but when Mandela was inaugurated, he wanted both Nkosi Sikelel’ iAfrika and the Afrikaans “Die Stem van Suid-Afrika” performed at his inauguration as an act of reconciliation. It was decided in 1997 to merge the two anthems and have five different languages in the verses. What an incredible story, and an incredible anthem.

The Conversation The Making of An Autocrat: the step-by-step guide that Trump is following, tried and tested the world over by the strongmen Trump seeks to emulate. Step 1: Hijack a Party Erica Frantz, associate professor of political science at Michigan State University, explains that Trump’s first step was to take control of the Republican Party, in his case as an outsider, and then to begin to dismantle democracy. Step 2: Recruit an Architect features Emma Shortis from RMIT, who says that autocrats always need an architect behind them. They are men (usually) who join the party young and use the party as a career ladder. Trump’s architect is Steven Miller, but we have seen others like Karl Rove and Dick Cheney. Step 3: Manufacture a Crisis A strongman loves a crisis, and Trump used the so-called ‘invasion’ of gangs as his crisis. It allows the autocrat to scapegoat a particular group and foment existing tension in order to go after his enemies, and to portray himself as a ‘hero’.

‘Regime Change’ by Jonathan Swan and Maggie Haberman

2026, 414 p. & notes

This book was so heavily publicized that you knew what it was going to say even before you started reading it. But I must admit that I was still shocked by what I read. The book covers Trump’s second presidency up to his attacks on Iran on February 27 2026, with a epilogue written in March 2026 when they interviewed him directly.

The subtitle of this book is “Inside the Imperial Presidency of Donald Trump”, and the term ‘imperial’ is apt. You get the sense of an all-powerful man, surrounded by acolytes, veering between mockery, rage and ennui, just as any Roman Emperor might have done.

I liked this description of his Oval Office:

By midway through the year, a picture was emerging of how the Oval Office operated in Trump’s second term. It was of a President spending his days at the Resolute Desk in a series of rolling bull sessions, accompanied by a core group of intimates; these were supplemented by a rotating cast of extras, and on any given day they could be Republican lawmakers, titans of industry, former pro wrestlers, country musicians, Gulf royals, crypto bros, or friends of felons seeking pardons. They would enter and exit the frame, with some invited to stay for meetings they had no business attending. The conversations ran fast, often straying far from the point, or from anything visitors imagined when they arrived at the White House. The President’s sentences often began on one topic and ended far away (p. 168)

The book is divided into four parts: Part I Whirlwind describing the initial weeks of the second Trump presidency, when he was released from the shackles that his first term team had placed on him, and juiced up by four years of planning his revenge. Part II is aptly named Retribution, as he pursued people who had acted against him in the intervening four years and as he ‘went after’ institutions like the Smithsonian Institute and the Kennedy Centre. Part III The Enemy Within explores his deployment of the National Guard and ICE agents, the shooting of Charlie Kirk and his attempts to indict James Comey and Letitia James. Part IV Plunder looks at his invasion of Venezuela and Trump’s yearning for the Nobel Peace Prize (what a joke!) and his deployment of Jarod Kushner and Steve Witkoff in the Middle East. The book then moves to Trump’s involvement in cryptocurrency and involvement with the tech bros. Trump then moves onto his ball room and Arc de Triomphe. The book comes to an end in February 2026 as Trump embarks on the Iran war.

My God, he is an awful man. Venal, obnoxious, vengeful and malicious. There’s nothing new in this book- we all know what he is- but such detail and the piling of event on event illustrates just how jaded and passive we have become. This is, of course, journalism- the first draft of history- but could the judgement of coming years be any more scathing than this?

And given that I’m posting this after the recent mid-term elections: thank God that democracy worked, in spite of all this.

My rating: 8.5/10

Sourced from: Yarra Plenty Regional Library

Read because: it was there on the shelf, and I was thinking of buying it anyway.

I hear with my little ear: Podcasts 8-15 October 2026

The Economist: Tocqueville Road Trip Episode 6: Capital of an Empire (subscriber only) In 1832 Alexis de Tocqueville arrived in Washington. President Jackson was president at the time, which is ironic because Trump has often expressed his admiration of him. The presenter, John Prideaux describes Jackson’s approach as protective of decentralization, but he was no dictator. He then speaks with Stephen Cash, a member a group called the Steady State, a network of intelligence community veterans who see Trump as heralding ‘competitive authoritarianism’. Prideaux is rather more sanguine, confident that the checks and balances of the system will come into play. So Prideaux decides to move on to Florida, a new centre of power where he talks with Alex Bruesewitz dubbed ‘one of the world’s most influential rising stars’ by Time Magazine, and a friend of Charlie Kirk and Donald Trump. Tocqueville had commented how presidents had royal prerogatives, which they didn’t have to use, but Prideaux notes that during the time he had spent making this podcast, Trump had started excusing himself and his family from scrutiny of their tax affairs, tried to sue the IRS and Taxation Dept, knocked down the East Wing of White House, and wanted to build a triumphal arch and have his face on the currency- in other words, Trump IS using the royal prerogatives available to him. Nonetheless, Prideaux remains optimistic about Democracy in America. (He’s deluded, I reckon). This is the final episode.

History Extra Did Britain Really ‘Keep Calm and Carry On’ During WW2? Well, until September 1938 people didn’t really take notice of the news that was coming from Europe. The pro-war consensus firmed up after Chamberlain admitted that appeasement wouldn’t work with Hitler. Handbooks were distributed that encouraged volunteer effort and 400,000 volunteers duly signed up. By April 1939 compulsory measures were introduced and in 1940 the Blitz began. In May 1940 a coalition government was formed to distinguish itself from Germany. Nonetheless, there was griping about the conditions in the air raid shelters, and people did flee to the countryside, even though the government tried to discourage this. There was skepticism, not about the war itself, but about the government response. Unlike in WW1 where the armed forces were the main people in peril, now fighting soldiers could be bereaved when their families died back ‘home’. Generally, there was well-meaning patriotism, and little of the cynicism and distrust that I think you’d see in the same situation today.

The Daily When AI Comes for Your Purpose in Life I read about how AI had solved one of mathematic’s long-standing problems. In this episode Steven Strogatz, a professor of mathematics at Cornell University, talks very emotionally about his mixture of excitement and grief at this news. It seems to me that humans are attracted to ‘problems’ not necessarily for the answer, but for their own intrinsic challenge that calls on insight and struggle. After all, who wants to do a crossword that has already been filled in?

The Documentary The politics of water: Iraq and Turkey

Two rivers helped build civilisation. Now they are at the centre of a geopolitical struggle that casts a shadow over the future of the Middle East. For centuries, the Tigris and Euphrates carried goods, armies and ideas, shaping some of history’s greatest empires. But today, a toxic mix of climate change, outdated irrigation methods and conflicting national interests is pushing these rivers to the brink. As Turkey’s vast dam projects reduce downstream flows, Iraq is being forced into negotiations that go far beyond water, touching on security cooperation, trade routes and energy. The Global Jigsaw tells the story of how water became a geopolitical bargaining chip.

Iraq or Mesopotamia is thought to have been the site of the Garden of Eden but it’s not that anymore. Both Turkey and Iraq have faced droughts, and Turkey has responded by building 800 dams which has reduced the flow of water by 1/3. The lessened water supply has affected the extraction of oil, and so diplomacy is now weighing up “oil for water” deals. It has been said that the wars of the 21st century will be about water, and you can see why.

‘Land: How the Hunger for Ownership Shaped the Modern World’ by Simon Winchester

2021, 411 p.

Prolific and popular historian Simon Winchester is always a good read, and I was interested in this book which promised a general history of land rather than a history of a particular geographical place. I expected that he would move from country to country in his analysis, and I was pleasantly surprised to find that he took a more thematic approach.

He starts with a fairly lengthy prologue of six chapters which mainly deals with his own purchase of 123 acres of forested and rocky mountainside in Amenia, in the state of New York- the first time that he had owned land anywhere. As with landscapes everywhere, his own little block had its own story to tell, going back to when it was part of the ancient continent of Laurentia, which was itself created about a billion years ago when a gigantic supercontinent split into Gondwana and Luarentia. It was peopled by homo sapiens, members of the Mohican tribe, who were felled by illnesses like smallpox, measles and influenza, and expelled from their lands and possessions. A subordinate tribe of the Mohicans, the Schaghticoke lived on for a bit longer, until many of them were turned off as well, with a few clinging on it the hope that treaties would be honoured. They weren’t. Their land was subdivided and, eventually, ended up owned by Simon Winchester after it had passed through several hands.

The book proper starts with Part I ‘Borderlines’ which traces the shift from hunter-gatherer society to a settled agricultural society where the concept of animal husbandry arises. Both agriculture and husbandry require boundaries, and the land is manipulated through ploughing and the use of animals to pull those ploughs. Surveying arose as a science, and the land was mapped. Borders could be between neighbouring plots of land, or between countries and later nations. He spends some time on the borders between India and Pakistan, and the mapping anomaly of the Lake of the Woods that straddles the 49th parallel between United States and Canada. (Don’t tell Trump; he’ll start a war over it).

Part II ‘The Annals of Acquisition’ looks at the phenomenon of obtaining land. He starts with man-made land and reclamation of land from wetlands, as in the Netherlands. He then turns to the British acquisition of land in North America, the Louisiana Purchase, and the great land rush in South Dakota which led to the expulsion of the Native American tribes, as the deluge of settlers continued on inexorably. The following chapter turns to landholding in England by the gentry, with a backwards look at the concept of ownership including the Domesday Book and the presence of the Romans in England.

Part III deals with ‘Stewardship’ picking up from the previous chapter and looking at the ‘Tragedies of Improvement’ through enclosure, and the expulsion of people from their lands in rural Scotland. He then turns to the huge landowners, looking at mine-owner Gina Rinehart in Australia, and huge American landowners like the founder of Cable News Network, Ted Turner, and his competitor John Malone, an engineering billionaire who also made his fortune through cable, and the Wilks brothers who have bought up a huge forest and rangeland empire in Idaho, Montana and down the Rockies to Texas. The Wilks have been dubbed ‘conservation evangelicals’ because they have been extreme in preventing people approaching their land by hiring security guards, dug anti-vehicle ditches and strung barbed-wire fences across public roads. He turns his attention to the concept of ‘trespass’ and fencing, then moves on to re-wilding, both unintentional (e.g. in the Demilitarized Zone between North and South Korea) and intentional (e.g. the Dutch polder in Flevoland, or Charles Burrell and Isabella Tree whose 3500 acre estate at Knepp in southern England has been a centrepiece of the rewilding movement). He returns his attention to Australia where, in counterpoint to Gina Rinehart’s mining activities, indigenous knowledge of the land presents a different form of stewardship. The public spaces of cities via parks and maidans are an acknowledgement and substitute for the loss of pastures and forests as they are replaced by asphalt and concrete. But in some places pollution and contamination (think plutonium, Chernobyl and Fukushima) have forced people from settled land permanently.

Part IV ‘Battlefields’ looks at conflicts over land, expressed by concepts of rule, possession and sovereignty, legal systems. This section is largely historical, although the three events who looks at are still all controversial (indeed two of them are active military conflicts). There is, of course, the creation of Israel, which he treats historically from the collapse of the Ottoman empire, and Stalin’s collectivization of Ukrainian agriculture- again, treated historically. He then turns to the appropriation of the land of Japanese farmers in the United States during World War 2.

Part V ‘Annals of Restoration’ looks at different movements worldwide to re-assert ownership of land. As this book was published in 2021, his chapter ‘Maori in Arcady’ may, I fear, be outdated because of recent moves to minimize the role of the Treaty of Waitangi in New Zealand His chapter on ‘Bringing Africa Home’ looks at land reform, which has had a chequered history with Robert Mugabe, Nelson Mandela, and the continuation of the ‘Happy Valley’ set in Kenya. He returns to Native American dispossession in America, and the Yosemite Land Grant where about 150 Miwok of the central Sierra live today and run the Black Oak Casino. He looks at land trusts in America, but saves up his venom for the island of Eigg in the Hebrides, where the community has taken over ownership after a succession of colourful private owners. He is sceptical of the politics surrounding these changes, which he sees as a form of social engineering, and he rather uncharacteristically steps out of his role as historian to become more of a commentator- and a critical one at that.

In his epilogue ‘Yet Now the Land is Drowning’ he rejects the idea that “land is the only thing on this earth that lasts” in the face of climate change. He picks up Leo Tolstoy’s question ‘How Much Land Does a Man Need?’ and ends with the observation that the protagonist in the story, Pakhom, eventually is buried in a hole six feet long and three feet wide.

As you can see, this is a wide-ranging book where he can indulge his story-lines of interest drawn from examples all over the world. It does have a bit of a “smooth the dying pillow” feel when he writes about indigenous cultures, and I don’t know if he explored ideas of modernity and the psychology of ownership as well as he could have. For the parts that I do know about- namely the Australian and New Zealand examples- he is basically accurate, if a little outdated, but that is inevitable as the world has swung to the right politically, cementing the place of elites who tend to hold, or seek, land. It’s eminently readable and interesting, and I’m pleased that he chose to take a thematic approach which lends itself better to digression and rabbit-holes.

My rating: 8/10

Sourced from: Yarra Plenty Regional Library.

I hear with my little ear: Podcasts 1-7 October 2026

The Rest is History I went to see the ‘Odyssey’ film and felt at rather a disadvantage because I’ve never read it. So, why not rely on the expertise of Dominic Sandbrook and especially Tom Holland, who are both very familiar with it. In Episode 687 The Odyssey: Hero of the Trojan Horse (Part 1) and Episode 688 The Odyssey: Return of the King they go through the book- neither of them have seen the film at this stage- and it was great to hear this before watching the screen interpretation.

The Weekend Intelligence Shire Folk: Episode 1 Tommy’s Town (might be subscriber only).

For 15 years the British media dismissed Tommy Robinson as a far-right extremist. We kept him off our televisions, and out of our newspapers.Today his rallies attract tens of thousands of followers and he has the ear of the world’s richest man. Shire Folk is the story of how some of the most powerful people in America came to see Britain—and Islam—through the eyes of a fringe football hooligan.

This episode starts in Luton, the home town of ‘Tommy Robinson’ (in reality Stephen Yaxley-Lennon). Football hooliganism had occurred for years, but the drug trade was taken over by Pakistanis, leading to turf wars. Then the War on Terror resulted in a radical Islam getting a grip in football. In March 2009 the English Defence League held an anti-Muslim march (as distinct from anti-Islamist), and Stephen Yaxley-Lennon changed his name to Tommy Robinson (a football hooligan). In 2013 Robinson walked away from the English Defence League, only to re-emerge in 2025 where he led a march of 150,000 people. Now, he has Elon Musk in his corner.

Stuff Matters Bananas: Is it the End of our Favourite Fruit? Bananas are cheap and not seasonal and Britain’s favourite fruit. The UK and America import their bananas (unlike Australia, which grows its own and good on us) and the banana industry was the first vertically integrated food sector. The bananas imported into UK and US are genetically identical, and can be imported green and ripened consistently in warehouses. Bananas were exported world-wide by the United Fruit Company, which has a rather shady history in the Caribbean and South America after becoming involved in enterprises far from bananas, at times with CIA involvement. However, the banana industry was nearly wiped out in the 1950s with the spread of Panama Disease, and the Gros Michel variety was replaced by the Cavendish. However since the 2010’s the Cavendish is also threatened by a new outbreak of Panama Disease caused by the strain Tropical Race 4 (TR4). Different countries are taking varied approaches to this threat: genetic modification, growing bananas alongside spring onions or zapping the bananas. It’s a good example of the vulnerability of a food chain in such an internationally integrated system.

‘Always Home, Always Homesick’ by Hannah Kent

2025,325 p.

I was well-primed to enjoy this book, having read all three of Hannah Kent’s published books: Burial Rites (review here) The Good People which I thought even better than Burial Rites (review here) and Devotion (my review here). It’s probably a bit ageist of me to express my skepticism when a ‘young’ person (i.e. anyone under 60!) writes a memoir, but in this case the term ‘memoir’ is a bit of a misnomer. The first part of the book is about her experience as an exchange student in Iceland as a 17 year old in 2003, and the second part is about the draw of Iceland that led to her writing her first book Burial Rites, the story of the last woman hanged in Iceland.

The book starts in Australia in 2020, with Hannah the mother to two children aged two years and three months. It is lockdown, and as with other Australian families she is enclosed within the circle of immediate family with her children and her wife Heidi. Inspired by a birthday video compiled by her friends in Iceland, she delves into a box of childhood memorabilia that her mother had brought around. She is mentally taken back to 2003 when, at the end of her formal schooling, and unsure of what she wanted to do with her life other than “be a writer” she had decided to go on a Rotary Exchange visit.

In that moment I know that this is for me. I know it. I know it in my bones, with a surety that runs through my body and makes me sit up as though I have been prodded in the back by life itself. This is what I need to do. This is the thing that will lead me further into life, that will allow me to breathe lung-deep of it. My certitude feels miraculous. (p. 28)

She is asked to nominate five countries, and having never seen snow before, she chooses Sweden, Norway, Finland, Switzerland and Canada- and hopes that the selection committee gets the gist. They do: and although they don’t send her to any of the countries she named, they do send her to Iceland. She would be one of only two Australian exchange students sent to Iceland that year.

The first half of the book deals with her experience in Iceland. Her first host family is quiet and reserved, although they probably fulfill their obligations in taking her to places and encouraging her to join a theatrical group. However, she cannot speak the language and is probably encased by the silent period that second-language learners often experience. It is only when she goes to a second family with four young children ( a family which was not intended to be her host family, but which saw her struggling) that her language begins to blossom and she begins to feel ‘at home’. But what her first foster family did do was to introduce her to the story of Agnes Magnusdottir, the last woman executed in Iceland and she finds herself drawn, at a deep psychological and even psychic level, to Agnes’ story. When she returns to Australia, excited at her acceptance into a Creative Writing course, she fears that she will forget the experience, forget her hard-won Icelandic fluency and lose Iceland itself “Iceland, I don’t know how to let you go” (p. 159)

Writing what became Burial Rites was how she kept her connection with Iceland. The second half of the book follows her research process over several years as she follows the archival sources, visits places and wrestles with the silences in the history. She eventually follows the ‘speculative biography’ methodology that Margaret Attwood utilized in Alias Grace, an approach of finding and writing ‘fictional likelihoods’. I enjoyed this part because I enjoyed the end product, but I do wonder if someone who hadn’t read Burial Rites would get much from it. After all, most historians (and novelists) have their own war-stories, which are probably of more interest to them and fellow historians and novelists than the general public.

Burial Rites was published in 2013 after an intense bidding war, and was instantly acclaimed both in Australia and internationally. I found myself wondering how Icelanders felt about an ‘outsider’ taking ‘their’ story- I can remember feeling a mixture of admiration and grudging resentment when English author Sarah Murgatroyd wrote the Burke and Wills story so well in ‘The Dig Tree’- but it seems that the book was well received. In fact, quotes from the book were integrated into a tourist trail that was constructed around Agnes Magnusdottir sites. It was important in her publicity for the book in Iceland that she spoke Icelandic, as part of confirming her credentials.

She captures well the ‘in-between’ status of a person who loves more than one home. When she is in one ‘home’, she misses the other. This ‘in-between’ness recurs when she has her second child, which is how she starts the book, which ends up being the memoir you are holding in your hand. In a way, this book would have been an ‘easy’ write, compared with her three other historical fiction books which required historical research, and it is an ‘easy’ read because her narrative voice is warm and engaging. If you had told me that this book was a ‘what I did on my exchange visit’ mixed with ‘how I wrote my first book’, I would have decided not to read it, but she is such a beautiful writer that she makes even these things compelling. Her descriptions of landscape are poetic, and the book has a human pull to it.

My rating: 8/10

Sourced from: purchased from Ladyhawke Books, Ivanhoe

Read because: Ivanhoe Reading Circle selection.

Movie: The Songs of John Farnham- The Celebration Concert

One of the most loved performers in Australia is John Farnham. He’s been around for decades and decades (yes, I remember watching him sing ‘Sadie the Cleaning Lady’ on Saturday morning television). Now I just love watching reaction videos where overseas commentators come across him for the first time, especially with his rendition of ‘Help’ as the finale encore of one of his generously long concerts.

This movie is a celebration of his music, performed with the knowledge that he is gravely ill with cancer. It is beautifully staged, and as with the National Theatre film productions, you get a better view than you would have had you been there- especially if you had selfish idiots standing up in front of you as some people did- I really don’t understand why people think that their ‘right’ to sway to the music in an aisle trumps the rights of everyone behind them to see.

But that’s a sour note, and I don’t want any sour notes here. I knew every song, and I knew nearly every performer, (they very helpfully provided the names for those of us thinking “Now who’s that again?”). Sitting there grinning like a fool and enjoying it, now and then I’d feel a wave of sadness sweeping over me that we’ll never again see him perform in person. This concert captured the Australia we used to be, before everything turned aggressive and vicious. I loved it. I think that it will be on television at the end of the year, but go to see it at the cinema with the bigger screen and sound system.

My rating: 5 stars.

‘Apeirogon, A Novel’ by Colum McCann

2000, 457 p.

If you’ve followed my reviews recently, you will have noticed that one of my pet peeves is the current fashion for novels to be constructed from a collection of disparate paragraphs, often separated by asterisks, where you are left as reader to impose your own structure of the disjointed narrative. On that basis, I should have hated this book, but I didn’t. Instead, I was deeply moved by it.

To be honest, I don’t even know how to pronounce the title, which refers to a geometrical term for “a shape with a countably infinite number of sides”, a definition which confuses me because I don’t know how something can be countable and infinite. This paradox is explored further:

As a whole, an apeirogon approaches the shape of a circle, but a magnified view of a small piece appears to be a straight line. One can finally arrive at any point within the whole. Anywhere is reachable. Anything is possible, even the seemingly impossible. At the same time, one can arrive anywhere within an apeirogon and the entirety of the shape is complicit in the journey, even that which has not yet been imagined. (p. 437)

Paradox lies at the heart of this book, which is based on the real-life experience of two men, Jewish Rami Elhanan and Palestinian Bassam Aramin, both of whom lost their daughters to the violence in the West Bank. Rami’s 14 year old daughter Smadar was killed in a suicide bombing, while Bassam’s daughter, 10 year old Abir, was shot in the back of the head by a rubber bullet after buying a candy bracelet at a store near her school. Together, and almost against their own wishes, they become spokesmen for Parents Circle, a group for bereaved parents, both Jewish and Muslim, who have lost their children to the violence. The two fathers travel the world together on speaking tours to small groups, schools (e.g. Bialik College in Melbourne in May 2023) or at literary/cultural events (e.g. the Wheeler Centre during the same tour- YouTube recording available here). Jewish Rami Elhanan is a peace activist; Palestinian Muslim Bassam undertakes academic research on the Holocaust. Even McCann’s strong proclamation by the very title of the book that it is ‘A Novel’ is a paradox, as the characters and events are all real, and the structure of the book is not novelistic as such.

Instead, it is 1001 small chapters- in fact, I don’t know if ‘chapter’ is the right word for them, as some are small black and white photos; others only one or two sentences in length. As such, it references the 1001 Arabian Nights. The first 499 lead up to a hiatus in the book where in chapter 500 Rami Elhanan tells his story in an extended narrative, followed by No 1001 which is a single page summary of the one-day action of the two men appearing at a presentation at a monastery in the mainly Christian town of Beit Jala near Bethlehem 2016. The countdown then goes in reverse, with chapter 500 being Bassam’s story in an equally extended narrative, then moving backwards towards a return to a darkness that echoes the opening chapter 1 at the start of the book.

Despite its kaleidescopic, fractured appearance, the book is actually very carefully structured. The deaths of the two daughters run throughout the 1001 chapters, but there are other motifs as well: birds, salt, numbers, silence and music. At times the chapters seem to be arranged in a form of clang-association. There is nothing random here.

This book was written in 2000, and I found myself wondering how this partnership would hold up after October 7 2023 with the Hamas attack on Israel in Gaza, and the following disproportionate retaliation. It seems, incredibly, that it has. But the book also illustrates the tragically inevitable attack of October 7 when Bassam’s anguished ambulance journey with his dying daughter whose transfer to a better-equipped hospital was obstructed, with an almost mocking nonchalance, by Israeli security forces. Rami’s life, while brought undone by grief, continues along well-oiled, prosperous lines; Bassam’s life, equally brought undone by grief, is constrained by petty and arbitrary humiliations. If this book is out-dated, it is also a lesson in inevitability and consequences.

This is a beautifully written, erudite, emotionally cutting book. I’m surprised that it didn’t make the short-list for the Booker Prize in 2020 after being long-listed. Too political? I thought it was excellent, and unfortunately just as important today as it was six years ago.

My rating: 10/10

Sourced from: Yarra Plenty Regional Library.