Author Archives: residentjudge

The Documentary (BBC) Ukraine: The Men Who Don’t Want to Fight I can remember reading and hearing reports of Russian men who were leaving Russia because they didn’t want to fight, but I wasn’t aware so much of reports of Ukrainian men doing the same. I’ve always had sympathy for men who didn’t want to fight in foreign wars in other people’s countries, but is it different if men are being asked to fight for their own country? I think that it is, although I’d be hard pressed to answer why. This episode looks at the more-than 6,000 Ukrainian men of military age who have been granted protection in Romania since the beginning of the war. Some did not want to fight for a variety of reasons; others had been on the frontline and walked away (‘deserted’?) Some had an easy escape; others died in the attempt. A different perspective on an old problem.

Emperors of Rome Episode LXXIX – Epicureanism Here’s something different. Matt Smith is nowhere in sight, and it’s Dr Rhiannon Evans who interviews Dr Sonya Wurster about Epicurianism, a Greek philosophy based on the idea that the greatest good is to seek modest pleasures- quite different from the high-status, elite idea that Epicurianism suggests today. It had four principles: 1. Don’t fear the gods 2. Don’t fear death 3. What is good is easy to get 4. What is bad is only of short duration. Many writers were hostile to Epicurianism because it was so laid-back that it didn’t fit into the Roman ideal of the politically involved citizen. Interestingly, many of the papyri that were discovered at Herculaneum (buried by Mt Vesuvius in 79CE in the same eruption that destroyed Pompeii) were works by Epicurian philosophers – in fact,in March 2023 a contest was launched to decipher the scrolls using AI. Throughout this series, Dr Rhiannon Evans and others have been referring to Dio Cassius (or Cassius Dio, take your pick) and in Episode LXXX – Dio Cassius he finally get his moment in the sun. He wrote about 80 books, of which we only have about 1/3 in their original form, but there are fragments and epitomes (i.e. summaries) of many of the others. He actually witnessed some of the things that he wrote about, which is always a bit tricky for a historian- at what point does the history become biography or journalism? This isn’t a problem that Livy fell into, as we learn in Episode LXXXI – Livy featuring Professor Emeritus Ron Ridley from Melbourne Uni who sounds like the quintessential classics scholar, enlivened by arcane debates about the past, and deeply embedded in all things ancient. Livy spent his whole life writing an exhaustive history of Rome – all 142 books, of which we have the first quarter. However, Livy was careful to stop before he got too close to the time when he was writing. They have been hugely influential on all the other histories that were written after him.

History Extra Having listened to the podcast about Ukrainian men avoiding fighting, I thought that I’d listen to Fight Like a Man? Masculinity in WW2 There was little relation between the two. This episode features Luke Turner, the author of Men at War: Loving, Lusting, Fighting, Remembering 1939-1945. As you might guess from the title, this book and podcast takes a gender/masculinities lens to look at WW2 and homosexuality, cross-dressing and gender-crossing during a time of such disruption, and when so many men lived in close proximity. It didn’t feel particularly new to me.

History Hit Part 3. Story of England: Tudor Feuds, Explorers and Fanatics takes us to (nearly) everyone’s favourite English period, the Tudors. Dan Snow starts off at Kenilworth Castle where he speaks Dr Joanne Paul who tells the intricate story of the powerful Queen Elizabeth I and her mutual infatuation with Sir Robert Dudley, to whom she gifted the castle. She points out that although Henry launched the Reformation as a way of getting round the problem of a lack of an heir, he remained Catholic in his practices e.g. he heard a Latin mass, and he had the Catholic last rites. Sir Robert Dudley spent a fortune on a 19-day visit by Elizabeth to his castle -1000 pounds a day on an income of 5000 pounds a year, and sent the family broke in the process. He then goes on to speak with Angus Konstam who explains about the Elizabethan Sea Dog (Drake, Raleigh, Hawkins), privateers who were both traders and explorers, and who laid the basis of England’s maritime power. He ends up at Boscobel House, where Charles II hid in the oak tree. Listening to Charles I’s bullying of the Parliament has a new relevance, now that we can see so many ‘strong men’ in erstwhile democracies, trying to subvert the power of the people.

Now and Then In There’s Something in the Water historians Heather Cox Richardson and Joanne Freeman look at the provision and privatisation of water in the development of American cities, focussing particularly on New York and Los Angeles. Coming in the wake of recent announcements about controls on the extraction of water from the Colorado River, it all seems rather reminiscent of our own struggles over the Murray River, with the conjunction of competing state interests, capitalism, exploitation and denial of the commons.

History Listen (ABC) Those Bloody Vegos- a short history of vegetarianism. Even though I flirted with vegetarianism in my early 20s, I have been known to utter “bloody vegos” once or twice. I suspect that some of the vegetarians of my acquaintance would be disconcerted to learn of the connection of vegetarianism with some rather out-there religious beliefs in the late 19th/early 20th century. This episode is Australian-focused, which was good to hear.

The Ancients. During May, The Ancients are having a series of podcasts on Babylon. This first one is about Nebuchadnezzar -I can barely even say it let alone spell it. He ruled between 605-562 BCE, forty-two years at the height of the Babylonian Empire when it reached from the Mediterranean to the Persian Gulf. He was himself the son of a king, so he had an easy accession to the throne. There was a power vacuum after the decline of the Assyrian empire, and both Babylon and Egypt vied to fill it. The Egyptians were propping up the King of Judea as a way of extending their power, but in 587 BCE Nebuchadnezzar beseiged Jerusalem and installed a client king. Ten years later, he captured Jerusalem and destroyed the first Temple. We get much of our information about him from the Jewish Old Testament, where he was seen as a historical figure, but also as a vehicle of God’s punishment. The Babylonian Empire was as large as the Assyrian empire had been, but in a slightly different place. Babylon was a religious centre and a trade route, with a lot of monumental building. During the 20th century, German archaeologists were very active in excavating sites. It’s not really known exactly where the Hanging Gardens of Babylon were (all large cities had gardens), and they were perhaps more ‘terraced’ than ‘hanging’. After reaching its peak under Nebuchadnezzar, the Babylonian empire didn’t last. After his death, his son was assassinated after 2 years, then his son-in-law met the same fate after four years. The last king of Babylon was unrelated to Nebuchadnezzar and in 539BCE the empire collapsed almost overnight in the face of the expansion of the Persian Empire.

Emperors of Rome Episode LXXVI – It’s Good to be the King. All the sources available to us portray Commodus as a Very Bad Emperor, worse than Caligula, Nero and Domitian. He wanted to rename Rome after himself, as well as ALL the months of the year. He portrayed himself as Hercules, and replaced Nero’s head on Nero’s column with his own, and had it placed beside what is now the Colosseum. Indulging himself as a gladiator was completely inappropriate- a bit like the Queen going on Big Brother. Episode LXXVII – Such was the End of Commodus At the end of his reign, he embarked on a killing spree amongst the Senate and the elites, while on all sides there were uprisings against the Roman Empire in Brittanica, Germania and in Dacia. There were omens of his demise: fires in Rome, and his own smearing himself with blood. He was planning on killing two of the consuls and becoming consul himself dressed up as a gladiator, so it was no surprise that he was assassinated on New Years Eve in 192 CE. His own concubine organized the hit, first with poison (that he vomited up because he was drunk) and then strangling, which was a particularly ignoble way to die. And that was the end of Commodus and the Antonine dynasty. Episode LXXVIII – Borders of the Roman Empire features Dr Paul Burton from ANU who notes that all of the British Imperialists of the 19th century would have imbibed ideals of empire from their shared classical education, bringing it right up to our days. During the republic, wars were mainly conducted against Carthage (North Africa) and the Hellenistic leftovers of Alexander the Great’s empire. The Roman army might be highly interventionist, but it would then withdraw- it wasn’t interested in annexing territory. New territory came as the spoils of victory and in fact, some Kings of neighbouring allies bequeathed their territory to the Romans. At first governors were sent to an area for one year only, but their period of office was gradually extended, which may have contributed to the fall of the Republic as governors (like Julius Caesar) embedded their power in provincial support. When Augustus promised an end to the civil wars, there was a change in mindset about the provinces: no longer were they cash-cows, but instead they were the site of building projects where local big men contributed the funding. This led to an expansion of the provincial elite to inclusion in the Senate, and even as emperors. Citizenship was highly valued (St Paul proclaimed his Roman citizenship to avoid being flogged) and it was used as leverage for loyalty. In 212CE Caracalla extended citizenship to everyone in the empire.

Latin American History Podcast The Conquest of Peru Part 8 Pizarro was able to enter Cusco without resistance, where Manco accepted Pizarro’s authority, and indeed all the power lay with the Spaniards. Manco then joined Almagro and Hernando de Soto in pursuit of Quizquiz. Finally turning to colonization instead of conquest, Pizarro established Lima as a port city. News of Peru’s riches spread, attracting the attention of both immigrants and other conquistadors already present in South America including Pedro de Alvarado, the most bloody of the conquistadors. Eventually de Alvarado was paid off, and he sailed away, leaving the north of Peru in the hands of the Spanish colonialists.

Dan Snow’s History Hit Continuing on his road-trip of British history in Episode 2 of Story of England: Medieval Invaders, Snow takes us to Pevensey where William the Conqueror and his Norman Invaders landed in 1066. The Duke of Normandy was a cousin of Edward the Confessor, who had just died, and he was taking his chances when this vacancy on the throne occurred. There are actually three Medieval periods: 1. Early Medieval (which used to be called the Dark Ages) between 400-1066CE; The Central period between 1066-1300, and Late Medieval from 1300-1500. The Early period was marked by increased regionalization of the Anglo-Saxon period, which settled into a few big kingdoms. Although we don’t know if King Arthur actually existed, it is true that Ambrosius Aurelianus certainly did, and aspects of his reign were probably incorporated into the Arthurian legend. The Vikings, who arrived in the 860s gobbled up the kingdoms, although Alfred the Great made a strong stand. Dan Snow then travels to Dover Castle, which was built after the Norman invasion, on a site previously occupied during the Iron Age, and by the Romans who left a lighthouse which still stands today. All this came to a halt in 1348 when the plague arrived, killing off 25 million Europeans during 1347-1352, and leading to a labour shortage, increased labour mobility, and a change in land use.

Democracy Sausage. I usually listen to this every week, but I don’t note it because it’s usually too topical and dates too quickly. But Mark Kenny’s The Queen is Dead with Stan Grant is excellent, and well worth a listen. It was a meet-the-author type event about Grant’s new book, but they also spoke about his contribution to the panel discussion prior to the coronation that culminated in him quitting as host of Q&A.

The Rest is History. With all the pearl-clutching about the faint embers of republicanism in Australia, it’s interesting to consider that in 1649 England declared a republic! It only lasted about ten years when, unable to get themselves out of what they had done, parliamentarians turned again to Charles II to fill the king-shaped hole. Featuring Anna Keay whose book The Restless Republic I’ve ordered from the library (these podcasts are not good for my already daunting TBR pile), this episode The Republic of Britain: Life Under Cromwell goes beyond the Cromwell/Parliament activities to look at the way that people either went along with it or changed their mind. I did a subject on this -ahem- fifty years ago, and had forgotten much of it, but what a fascinating time, with radical political experiments turbocharged by radical religiosity.

The Documentary (BBC) Beirut: Life in the Unliveable City I love my home city, Melbourne, and I just can’t imagine what it would be like to watch it collapse economically, politically and socially around me. I think of Caracas in Venezuela, Argentina in the grip of inflation, and Beirut in Lebanon. Lina Mounzer is a writer and translator living in Beirut, and here she talks with friends, family and neighbours about what it is like to live there. She lives on the 12th floor of a high-rise, and even though they pay to have a generator, they only receive 12 hours of electricity a day, on an intermittent basis. She overlooks the port and the grain silos that block her view saved her flat when other silos exploded three years ago. In explaining the political situation, she goes back to 1991 and the end of the Civil War when an amnesty froze everything, but also granted immunity to those who had committed atrocities. In 2019 there was a financial collapse, leading to massive 97% devaluation of the currency, followed by the port explosion in 2020. Now 80% of the people live in poverty, with 25% in extreme poverty. Since November 2022 there has been no president. She has seen the rise of ‘generator mafia’, a sector of the economy that owns generators and which now is bigger than the official electricity system in its heyday, so it is unlikely that the electricity situation will improve in the future.

History Hit Dan Snow has started a five-part series on the history of England. In this first episode Story of England: Stone Age to Roman Days, he starts with the footprints on the mudflats at Happisburgh, Norfolk which were made about 900,000 years ago on what was at that time the banks of the Thames. We don’t know what species of humans made the prints, because there have been at least four species of humans in England. There were at least eleven waves of migration to England, and climate plays an integral role. In warm periods there were rhinos; in cold periods there were polar bears. During the Ice Age in 25,000 BCE, human life in England ceased completely, but humans returned again in about 15,000 CE. He then moves on to Stonehenge, which was commenced c. 8000-7000 BCE, with the biggest stones erected in c2500 BCE. The largest stones were collected from about 20 miles away, but the smaller ones, called ‘bluestones’ (though not bluestone as we know it) come from Wales. The stones reflect a solar alignment, and there are acoustic properties to the bluestones. No-one every lived there: it was a ceremonial site. He then moves to Old Sarum. Julius Caesar had brought the Romans over in 54-55 BCE but it wasn’t until 43 CE that Claudius mounted a ‘proper’ conquest. Sarum was already a fort, and the Romans built a temple on it and expanded it further. It became an Anglo-Saxon centre, and when William the Conqueror invaded in 1066, he headed straight for it. This was a really well-produced episode, interesting, and giving enough context that an Antipodean could follow it easily.

Revisionist History. The Mystery of Mastery with Adam Gopnik. This was a taped interview where Gopnik (who I’ve only encountered in the New Yorker) is talking about his new book The Mystery of Mastery. Rather than talk about the book itself, they ramble on about mutual acquaintances and men that Gopnik had encountered who exhibited mastery- magicians, cooks etc. So far the only woman they discuss is one of their mothers rolling out pastry (although Gopnik’s mother is a professor, he says) and I decided I’d had enough of this dickfest.

Emperors of Rome Episode LXXIII – From a Kingdom of Gold Marcus Aurelius died at the age of 59, still with the army fighting yet another phase of the Marcomannic Wars. He probably died of plague, which was still circulating around, although some sources suggest that he received ‘help’ from doctors. He was deified and buried in Hadrian’s mausoleum. His reputation is somewhat tainted by Commodus who followed him, but it is quite clear that Marcus always wanted him as a successor. The ‘five good emperors’ were all adopted, but by pushing his (unsuitable) biological son, he broke the pattern. Marcus Aurelius was really important: he satisfied the senators and he didn’t alienate anyone. He was unfortunate to face two wars and the plague, and he probably would have been an excellent civic emperor, rather than a military one. Episode LXXIV – Iron and Rust In his book, The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, Gibbons starts off with Commodus, and anyone who has seen Gladiator will agree. The Roman Empire did begin to lose power at this time, which was perceived as being caused by Commodus’ own immorality. Well, this is what Cassius Dio says, who was an eyewitness and participant- so who knows how objective and reliable he is. Some of his most egregious actions were only picking up on similar actions in the past, but in Commodus’ case, he was actively trashing the Roman Empire. He quickly contracted truces in the Marcomannic Wars which kicked the problem further down the road, and then turned up in Rome for his triumph, along with his boyfriend. He had inherited a good, happy Senate but started executing them, and reverted to treason trials and confiscations as a way of replenishing the coffers. There was an assassination attempt led by his sister Lucilla, so he purged the Senate and the upper classes and put his own men in. Episode LXXV – Flying Too Close to the Sun looks at men who stepped forward to fill the administrative and leadership vacancy while Commodus was off indulging in “orgiastic abandonment” as Cassius Dio puts it. Sextus Tigidius Perenni was the Praetorian Prefect. He lasted a couple of years but was brought undone when 1500 javelin men arrived from Britain, dissatisfied with the Roman government, and Commodus took their side. He was replaced by Cleander, who had facilitated the arrival of the British contingent so that he could get rid of Perenni. He enriched himself (and Commodus) by selling off public office, leading the situation where there were 24 consuls each year- 25 if you count Commodus. But there was a grain shortage and a crowd protest at the races against Cleander and Commodus meant that Commodus had Cleander executed and threw his head to the crowd.

The Rest is History. My grandfather was a Freemason. He died before I was born, but his lodge briefcase was in the garage. Even though my father was not at all interested in Freemasonry, he became very angry when we dressed up in the apron and regalia to parade around the backyard. I’ve visited our local Masonic temple, but I really do not understand it one little bit. So I was interested in this episode The Freemasons: History’s Greatest Conspiracy Theory features John Dickie, whose book The Craft I have reserved at the library. He refutes the lore that Freemasonry started with King Solomon, identifying instead the court of James VI of Scotland (later James I of England) who introduced the stonemasons to the concept of the ‘memory palace’ as a way of remembering the material for entry to the craft. Then in 1717 four lodges formed the Grand Lodge, severing the connection to real-life stonemasonry, and created the 1723 Rule Book. It was associated with Whiggery, and fear of the French Revolution; its ideas influenced the American Revolution, and it did the hard work of the British Empire in providing a web of support for men sent to the colonies, and forming a meeting ground of sorts with the local elite, especially in India. Franco hated them, and they were involved in the Vatican Banker scandal of the 1970s in Italy. I’m looking forward to the book.